Op-Ed: Art d’Egypte’s Forever Is Now is Nothing But a Mediocre Photo Op

Their investment is not in culture, but in the neoliberalization of heritage and the over commercialization of art.

A view of the monumental installation titled 'Time to Plant Love,' by Chinese artist Jiang Qiong Er presented as part of the 'Forever is Now Art D'Egypte' exhibition.
“Is the Egyptian economy benefiting from this exhibition? Anyway, the Pyramids are there and they’re what’s attractive, not the metal piece placed in front of them.” - Heba Attia Moussa.

Art D’Égypte’s Forever Is Now exhibition is the latest annual tradition in the grand history of the Great Pyramids of Giza. This November, for the sixth year in a row, international artists are invited to bring their works in conversation with the pyramids. Most media have been praising these attempts, but most Egyptians have a different opinion: Forever Is Now is nothing but a mediocre photo op. 

Art D’Égypte has been operating in Cairo for the past ten years, but the capital’s local art scene has given it little attention. There have been few serious reviews or genuine critical engagements with the works on display. 

“Since they launched, I wasn't comfortable with this idea of one cultural organization exhibiting in the Pyramids area with hardly any Egyptian artists,” urban planner Heba Attia Moussa tells OkayAfrica. “And the pieces themselves are quite suspiciously weird. They look like something from a furniture store, but scaled up.”

This year, the Egyptian art scene decided that enough was enough when Forever Is Now invited Bernar Venet, a French sculptor with links to Israeli art institutions. A grassroots petition with over 700 signatures pressured the company into cancelling Venet’s contract. 

“I think Art D’Égypte is never going to be the same again, because they’re now in the public eye and have to take the local art scene more seriously,” says writer, translator and cultural organizer Mohamed Addakhakhny. “You can be a sellout, whatever, but inviting an apartheid sympathizer broke the consensus.” 

Who gets to make contemporary art in Egypt? 

At the exhibition opening, Art D’Égypte Founder Nadine Abdel Ghaffar said that the aim was always for the world to see Egypt “not only for the extraordinary history we inherited, but for the creativity we continue to produce today.” 

If the goal is to show contemporary Egyptian art, why is painter Emad Abu Grain this year’s only Egyptian artist on display? “Locals and non-whites appear as a mere token,” says Addakhakhny. “Art D’Égypte is not interested in a conversation with the art scene here whatsoever. They think that they’re doing the art scene here a favour by bringing people that we’ve never heard of before.” 

Who has a right to the pyramids?

On their website, Art D’Égypte claims “to position Egypt at the forefront of the international contemporary art scene, bridging heritage and innovation in a place built, to be looked at forever.” This place, the Great Pyramids of Giza, is not easy to rent. Most Egyptian artists will never get the chance to exhibit their work anywhere near that plateau, which is one of the main criticisms local artists raise against the company. 

This edition of Forever Is Now is staged under the patronage of the ministries of Foreign Affairs and Tourism and Antiquities, alongside the Egyptian Tourism Authority. “The way Art D’Égypte operates is the only way to operate in a sphere that is so apolitical,” says Addakhakhny. “It’s a space where the state apparatus and neoliberal comprador investors can overlap, because the state is so eager to commercialize heritage. It’s a great PR event for the state, real estate companies, [Abdel Ghaffar] herself, and mediocre Western artists.”

A comprador is a native agent who works for foreign businesses, investors, or colonial powers in a colonized country; they’re the intermediary between the North and South, not in an equal, but in an exploitative relationship. 

Drawing on David Harvey’s book Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution, Moussa explains the concept of monopoly rent, when one organization makes profit off of the uniqueness of a place. “It’s a clear example of gentrification. Not in the sense that we know in residential neighborhoods, but gentrification of a site that belongs to Egyptians and humanity, but one organization takes monopoly over it,” she says. “They invest in selected elements, not in the local culture but in the things that will maximize their profit. A few capitalists make a lot of money out of a collective value and culture.” 

“Allegedly, they are also extremely underpaying their staff and don’t provide them with adequate working conditions,” adds Dakhakhny. 

It’s doubtful that travellers and art lovers come to the Pyramids specifically for the Forever Is Now exhibition. “[Most of the visitors are in a] network of a few investors who come for the photo-op,” says Moussa, referencing the attendance of people like Michael Bloomberg, Laurent Fabius, the former Prime Minister of France, and Princess Heide von Hohenzollern. 

“We should be able to participate in the site collectively, instead of it being exclusive to a few international artists,” she says. “The people who have shaped this environment [for centuries] are now being cut out of this, which is really a shame.” 

A rebellious art scene

When people found out about Venet’s invitation, they not only petitioned for him to be uninvited, but also looked into the inner makings of Art D’Égypte. Abdel Ghaffar leads a commercial firm which operates under the umbrella of UAE-based Culturvator and a Delaware non-profit of the same name.

“What we are looking at, then, is a tax-exempt American entity, funded by an Emirati real estate conglomerate, monopolizing the right to exhibit art in front of the Pyramids under the banner of sponsoring Egyptian art and artists,” writes Ahmed Naji on Almanassa.

The Instagram account @ziodegypte uncovered Abdel Ghaffar’s close connection with several zionists who have fundraised for the IDF and/or enjoy links with Israeli art institutions. The anger about this happening on Egyptian soil, where most of the population disapprove of their government’s normalization with Israel, led artists to speak up. 

“It was inspiring to me that the local community of artists and cultural organizers were active. That's a rare moment for Egypt, because it's very hard to be politically active now,” says Moussa. “It’s hard to raise a petition and for this petition to actually make an impact, especially when it comes to people who are so well connected that they can rent out the Pyramids.”

“We were kind of surprised that we’re still capable of doing something in a moment when we all feel socially, culturally, and politically disabled,” agrees Addakhakhny.

While the local Egyptian art and urban scenes remain critical of Forever Is Now, their intervention and consequent removal of Venet was only the beginning. “We need a wider cultural discussion about who benefits from heritage sites and who gets to access them, how to access them, and the transparency around profits and money flow,” says Moussa. 

“There was a time when we could afford just despising them or being indifferent, but now that indifference and contempt transformed into hatred,” says Addakhakhny. “You're not just stealing our right to the Pyramids, but you're being part of the manufacturing of consent on the genocide. Fuck off for that.”